Goodnight Fatty Menu

Goodnight Fatty offers a cozy bakery experience centered on warm, comforting treats that invite you to slow down and savor simple pleasures. The menu features a variety of soft, freshly baked cookies in creative flavors that change regularly, alongside classic favorites like muffins, doughnuts, and bagels. Perfect for a mid-afternoon break or an evening indulgence after a day of exploring Salem, these sweet bites pair naturally with their creamy soft serve ice cream and nostalgic milk options.

The atmosphere here is casual and friendly, making it easy to pop in for a quick snack or linger over a flight of cookies and a mixed swirl ice cream. Whether you’re seeking a familiar taste with a twist—like the Salted Pretzel Cookie or the S’Mores Cookie Vegan—or aiming to try something unique like the Nutella Bomb Fatty, the menu is designed to feel approachable and comforting. The rotating cookie flavors add a sense of everyday discovery, creating moments that feel both cozy and a little special during any visit.

Goodnight Fatty’s offerings complement the warmth of the space, where the aroma of fresh baking invites you to take a moment and enjoy a simple, satisfying experience. The combination of soft, gooey cookies with creamy ice cream brings a touch of nostalgia, connecting the treat to familiar, comforting memories. It’s a spot where the menu’s simplicity encourages enjoyment at any time—whether as a late-night sweet or a casual daytime snack.